FICTION
by Midge Raymond
She’s standing in line at the registration table when she sees him, two writers ahead. Sun-spritzed brown hair, strong hands. A hint of crow’s feet indicating he’s maybe fortysomething. No wedding ring. When he leans over the table to sign a form, she admires his pen, a Montblanc, shiny black with its signature bloom of snow at the top.
When she arrived on campus that afternoon and crossed the lawn, she felt a sort of anticipation—maybe it was the lush green of late summer: the grass thick, the trees overripe with leaves, the sun’s fluttering shadows underneath. She’s optimistic about the week ahead, in part thanks to last night’s yoga class, during which she finally managed to hold tree pose for more than a few seconds. When you can’t balance your body, you can’t balance your life, her instructor says—and Rachel has been out of alignment for a long time, wobbling through her days on weak ankles, on shaky knees. But last night, standing on one leg, arms raised high in the air, she felt as though that moment of steadiness was a sign her life was headed in the right direction, for once.
After she checks in, she gathers up her housing assignment, her key and name badge, the schedule of workshops and readings and meals. As she looks around, she sees writers chatting with one another and suddenly feels like the new girl in school who’s arrived midyear. She decides to go straight to her dorm room to fit in a few minutes of meditation.
As she’s heading for the door, head lowered to read the evening’s schedule, she feels the sudden jolt of colliding with another body, hears the clatter of an object hitting the floor and skittering to a stop next to her sandaled foot.
The Montblanc.
She leans down to pick it up. The name Todd Bennett blooms in silver—or is it platinum?—across the cap.
She holds it out to him. “It’s beautiful,” she says. “I’ve always wanted one of these. Like it might make me feel like a real writer.”
“It hasn’t helped me yet,” he says with a laugh.
“I’m a technical writer,” she offers. “I’m just getting started writing fiction.”
“Sounds familiar,” he says. “Twenty-two years in Silicon Valley, and now I’m writing a novel.”
That explains the suntan. “I miss California,” she says. “I’m here in Portland now, but I used to live in San Diego.”
“I just got back from visiting there,” he says. “It’s gorgeous. Why’d you give it up for the northwest gray?”
“I left after the wildfires,” she says. “I lost my house.”
“Oh,” he says. “Wow, sorry to hear that.” He looks taken aback, and she feels bad for springing it on him like that. Then his expression changes, and he asks, “Your name’s not Rachel, by any chance?”
She pulls her name badge out of her pocket and holds it up. “That’s me,” she says.
“And you submitted a piece about a fire?”
“That’s right.”
“We’re in the same workshop.”
Rachel feels herself straightening a bit, as if she’s reminding her body—or it’s reminding her—that she’s about to readjust her life. As if she can feel her vertebrae shifting along her spine, allowing everything to fall into place.
*
In her room, she doesn’t bother with meditation. Instead, she takes out the stack of manuscripts for the workshop—seven of them, short stories and novel excerpts, which they were all supposed to read ahead of time so they’d arrive at the conference ready to offer critique.
Todd’s piece had been one she’d skimmed and dismissed, thinking she’d come up with something to say during the workshop. But now she rereads it—a chapter from some sort of techno-thriller—and remembers her first reaction, which was to wonder how a guy writing genre fiction got accepted to a supposedly literary conference. But now she’s looking closer, convincing herself that his sentences have a certain energy, that his words leap off the page, animated in a way she doesn’t see as she pores over literary magazines, studying all the ways in which she might improve her own writing. As her eyes move down the page, she tries to picture him writing these words, wondering where and how he writes, whether it’s just before sunrise or in the dark quiet of the midnight hours.
Then she puts his pages down, shaking her head to clear him from her mind. She gets into the lotus position and breathes.
She began yoga classes when her loneliness began to feel like something invading her body—a shriveling sensation, as if she were shrinking from the inside out. She’s been taking both yoga and meditation for a year, yet she still feels as though she isn’t doing it right. She’ll sit in the quiet studio listening to others’ breathing, wondering if they are one with the universe or whether they’re as conscious of every passing moment as she is.
She likes the idea of the fluidity of time, and this is what keeps her coming back. In one class, they explored their past lives by lighting candles and placing them six inches away, with a mirror another six inches away on the other side. During meditation, they were supposed to be able to see a past life reflected in their own eyes. Yet all Rachel could see was the flicker of gold in the dark, muddy brown of her eyes—no story, no answers, just a rutilant shadow in a hollow space.
*
After Joel died, she started taking classes, sometimes two or three at once, as a way to distract herself. It hadn’t worked. She dropped out of ceramics because her vases were lopsided. She took self-help classes—Mindfulness & Self-Compassion, Living Well After Loss, The Foundational Role of the Body—and even those left her feeling like a failing student among straight‑A peers. Comparison is the root of all heartache, her therapist told her—but she still couldn’t help doing it. Her whole life had been based on comparison, on competition, and even though Joel wasn’t there any longer, she continued to play the game, even if she was competing with only herself.
*
At the welcome party, Rachel carries around a plastic cup of sickeningly sweet chardonnay as she wanders through the room. Her eyes come to rest on an auburn-haired woman with a rosy, anticipatory flush in her features. It takes Rachel a moment to realize that the woman is sitting next to—and flirting with—Todd. As Rachel makes her way over, she nudges her way through the crowd, jostling her cup of wine, spilling a few drops at Todd’s feet.
“Oh, I’m so sorry,” she says.
“Hey,” he says, and smiles.
“I was just going for another glass of wine,” Rachel says. “Can I bring you guys anything?”
“I’ll go with you,” he says, and looks at the auburn-haired woman. “Merlot?”
The woman nods.
As they wait at the bar, Rachel learns that Todd is staying in the same dormitory, his room a flight below hers. “Who’s your roommate?” she asks.
“I don’t have one.”
“Lucky you.”
Her own roommate, Vivian, is a shy, serious writer who Rachel imagines will be asleep every night by ten o’clock—not one to sneak in before dawn wearing last night’s clothes, shoes damp with morning dew.
Rachel thinks back to her days in college: squeezing into top bunks at frat houses, quickies in the library basement, the feel of ocean air on her skin through open windows. She didn’t recognize then—not until last year, in a seminar on embodiment practices—that she was seeking connection, seeking love, through these myriad physical encounters. Yet unlike many of her fellow seminar classmates doing experiential work, she didn’t see herself as a victim. She wasn’t.
“I wouldn’t mind a roommate,” Todd says. “This whole thing is kind of fun, like being back in college.”
“I was thinking the same thing,” she says.
When they return to where they’d left the auburn-haired woman, she is no longer there. “We can’t let good merlot go to waste,” Todd says.
“I won’t even let bad merlot go to waste.” She takes a sip from the cup, anticipating tomorrow’s headache. She likes the way his eyes linger, the way his gaze sends a shiver up her misaligned spine. “So,” she says, “what did you think of my story?”
He studies her for a moment. “Pretty wild,” he says.
“Hmm,” she says. “I’m not sure how I should take that.”
“Either you have a hell of an imagination, or I should stay far away from you.” His lips turn upward, and she laughs.
“So what did you think of mine?” he asks.
She doesn’t tell him that she had to reread it, or that when she saw his words that second time she also saw his fingers on the keyboard and imagined them against her skin.
“You’ll find out in the workshop,” she says, and takes another drink of the bad merlot.
*
Rachel joins the five other writers in a circle, including the auburn-haired woman, whose name is Christina. The setup is not unlike her meditation group; here, though, the chair desk makes her feel awkward and vulnerable. Julia, the instructor, does an introduction, gives them an exercise, and then starts the critique. Rachel’s story is first in the lineup.
“‘Firestorm’ is about love and family and regret,” Julia begins, “and the first thing I’d like to focus on is the main character, on her credibility.”
Rachel muses on the word credibility—a notion that comes up often as she writes. The story of Joel has been the story of her own life, too, but her therapist asks: How long do you want to own that narrative? He mentioned a word to her—chernophobia, the fear of joy—and suggested that avoiding joy may be her way of keeping him alive.
“The main character’s emptiness really comes through in this piece,” Julia continues. “But does she find redemption here, when she moves to Portland and starts over? Can she really start over, after what she did?”
“It’s believable to me,” Todd volunteers. “Anyone can start over. At least, we like to think so.”
“I’m not sure this character’s redeemable,” says Christina. “To let her brother die in the fire like that?”
“I don’t see it as that black-and-white,” Todd says. “If she’d tried to rescue him, they may both have died. It was more self-preservation than selfishness—that’s how I read it.”
Julia breaks in. “What if the fire is a metaphor for something else?”
A couple of murmurs hum through the room, and the group continues to pick apart the story as Rachel pretends to take notes. The writer is not allowed to talk during the critique session, and when they finish and take a break, Rachel pushes a strand of hair from the sweat on her forehead.
She sees Todd in the hall, at the vending machine. “Critiques are tough,” he says. “Buy you a drink?” He smiles down at her as she accepts the cold can of iced tea.
They step outside and stand under the shade of a large oak tree. “Thanks for being kind in there,” she says. “I’ve taken writing classes before but nothing quite like this. I didn’t realize how hard it would be.”
“Well, I meant what I said.”
She likes the way his eyes never leave hers. “We better get back,” she says.
*
At that evening’s readings, Rachel sits alone, near the back of the theater. The podium is a work of art itself, carved into the shape of a bird’s wings, reaching up and outward. When writers stand behind it, with their hands on their pages, their arms disappear behind the pale wood, and as they read they look like winged creatures themselves, as if they are soaring. When Rachel closes her eyes, the dark silhouette that remains in her vision is that of a black angel against a gold background.
The fiction writers wear skinny jeans and heels. The poets wear long skirts and hip eyeglasses. They all seem to be dark-haired and smart, their hair pulled back in an artful disarray, as if they can’t be bothered with appearance. Rachel, in her loose jeans and Tevas, her highlighted blond hair falling around her shoulders, can’t help but wonder whether she’ll ever fit in.
She listens without hearing, thinking instead about the workshop. When Todd’s story had come up for critique, she’d returned his kindness, commenting favorably on the immediacy of the language, the novelty of the genre. She could tell he appreciated it, but she felt like a fraud. And now she’s worried about the assignment Julia has given them: a short story of a thousand words, due on the penultimate day, to be critiqued on the last. Rachel has no idea whether she’ll be able to write something new in such a short time.
She takes a deep breath, wondering whether she has any stories of her own anymore, whether she ever did. When she was growing up, her parents had limited resources, and these resources—money, love, attention—went to Joel, as they had to. It was simple math. Everything Rachel had went to him, too.
It began with a soccer injury, or so they thought. He began complaining of pain in his knee, which seemed to get worse at night and then became excruciating during practice. It wasn’t until the knee began to swell that they went to see a doctor, who suggested wrapping it and taking a few weeks off from soccer. Months later, they finally saw a specialist, then another, and then came the diagnosis, a hideous-sounding word: osteosarcoma. It was rare, and serious, and required surgery and chemo and radiation. He was sixteen years old; Rachel was fourteen.
She did not know then that there were things in life you couldn’t prepare for, couldn’t overcome. By the time Joel’s cancer had spread to his lungs, by the time he had trouble breathing and spent weeks at a time in the hospital hooked up to an O2 machine, she was spending most of her time with him, watching movies, playing the Mad Libs word games their mother had given them to pass the time. When they ran out of pre-printed stories, Rachel began making them up herself, with Joel filling in the blanks: stories about their parents, their dog; about the hospital employees; about the people they knew at school, who were already disappearing from Joel’s world, and hers. She wrote about the glamorous futures they would have, the story of him learning to drive, the story of her going to senior prom. None of it happened, and it wasn’t until she took a writing class in Portland that she realized she’d been writing fiction all along—that the stories she and Joel told each other were truer than anything, and yet not real at all.
She knew the writers in the workshop would find her fire story disturbing, even as fiction. Rachel begins to wonder whether the actual fire, as Julia suggested, was a metaphor for something else—a symbol of purification, a signal to move on?
That her family home actually did burn down, along with dozens of others during that year’s fire season, told her more than anything that it was time to leave. She’d deferred college for a year, then another, until Joel was gone. By then she couldn’t imagine leaving her parents alone in their grief, so she lived at home while she attended the local university, where as a commuter student she made only a few casual friends and didn’t have much of a social life. And when she graduated and looked for work, it felt easier still to look for local jobs and keep living at home.
When they got the Reverse 9–1‑1 call to evacuate, they had an hour to leave the neighborhood, and Rachel took very little of her own belongings; like her parents, she took whatever she could of Joel—clothes and books, laptop and phone, photos and baby books—all from his still-untouched bedroom. At the time, it felt wrong, somehow, almost as if they were stealing, but in the end Rachel was grateful for everything they’d taken with them. Even as they stood, two days later, at the burned-out shell of their home, all three of them were dry-eyed and calm. Rachel overheard the fire marshal say something about their being in shock, but she knew it wasn’t that. The loss of the house was nothing, really; they’d already lost everything.
At first, Rachel thought moving away would change her life. In Portland, she’d rented a room in the Hawthorne district, in an old house filled with clocks that chimed every quarter hour. She didn’t sleep for three nights—it wasn’t just that she knew exactly how late it was, that she’d memorized the order of the clocks’ chiming, anticipating the sound of each one, the chimes longer as they stretched toward midnight, then short again in the early hours—it was that, with each gong, she felt another piece of her own life disappearing.
She hardly notices that the reading is over until people rise from their seats and begin to shuffle out. She lingers behind, then finally goes outside, the campus dark and shadowy, the day’s warmth still hovering in the air.
She meanders along the curving paths, and it’s late by the time she makes her way back to the dorm, where she sees Todd sitting on the steps, talking to Christina. Christina is freckly and strikingly pretty, with a long, lean body that Rachel can picture wrapped around Todd’s like a pretzel. One look from Christina tells Rachel that she’s unwelcome, and for a moment Rachel is tempted to sit down, to slip off her shoes and stretch her legs, catlike and mean. But she remains standing as she says hello, one foot on the step in front of her, ready to ascend.
They chat briefly about the day’s workshops, about how the air feels like rain. Then Rachel says, “I’ll see you later,” and starts up the stairs.
Todd says, “No, sit down, join us.”
Rachel hesitates. “All right,” she says to Todd, then adds, “if you’re sure you don’t mind.”
She sits down on the other side of Todd, and a few minutes later Christina gets to her feet. “I’ve still got some reading to do,” she says. “See you tomorrow.”
Rachel feels a twinge of guilt and tries to ignore it. A raindrop hits the concrete, and moments later, the skies open up.
“I’ve got some wine upstairs,” Todd says.
His room looks like any other dormitory on move-in day—blank-walled, institutional—though it bears small details of the man sleeping there: the bottle of syrah, the laptop, the half-open duffel bag.
He pours wine into plastic cups, and they click them together with a dull, flat sound. They sit opposite each other on the twin beds and make small talk about the readings. Then Rachel swallows the last of her wine and stands up—but Todd waves her back down and gets up to refill their cups. This time, he sits next to her on the bed.
“I’m still thinking about your story,” he says. “Tell me what inspired it.”
She takes another sip of wine. “The house burning to the ground, mostly,” she says.
“I know,” he says. “I meant, the other stuff.”
“It’s fiction,” she says.
“You remember what Julia told us about Kurt Vonnegut,” he says. “He said to write about what you care about, what you think other people should care about.”
“What does that have to do with me?”
“I’m wondering what you want us to care about.”
Rachel looks at him and wonders what would be different if he knew. Maybe it wouldn’t matter at all. His eyes are still on hers, and then he leans forward, until his face is close.
She lets her lips meet his. He kisses her with a slight pause, a hesitation, before pulling her close. She takes his cup and puts it on the bedside table, along with hers, then folds her leg up on the bed so she can get closer. As their bodies ease backward, the bedsprings creak under them—weary, she imagines, from the dozens, if not hundreds or thousands, of lovers here in the dorms before them.
Their shirts are off, hands reaching for buttons and zippers, and then he buries his head in her shoulder with a sigh. “We shouldn’t.”
“Why?”
As he seems to waver, on the verge of saying something else, she reaches for him again, and nothing about him—nothing about this part of him, anyhow—hesitates this time. He draws in a sharp breath, and they shed the rest of their clothes. And whatever he was about to say is forgotten.
*
The next day in workshop, Todd won’t look her in the eye. She tries to act as though he’s just another body in the room, and when the workshop is over, she leaves without a backward glance.
It reminds her of why she’d sworn off men recently—they never seem to understand that a night of sex doesn’t mean she wants to marry them—and why her relationships have always been so short-lived. She’d made no time for boys in high school, and once in college and beyond she was drawn toward men who, like her, wanted nothing resembling commitment. Yet still she sought something, and this elusive something showed up in the things she keeps in a closet in her apartment, a dark, cramped graveyard of past relationships, a jumble of random items: a lone golf club, the left half of three pairs of shoes, a fraternity mug, a tennis racquet. She doesn’t know why she takes these things, only that it’s an instinct, a way of grasping something she can’t otherwise hold onto. And for all their clutter, these objects seem to take up negative space; they reveal an emptiness her crowded closet belies.
She doesn’t see Todd again until later that night; he’s sitting alone at the evening readings. She takes the seat next to his. She stares straight ahead, feeling his head turn, his eyes on her face. She ignores him for most of the reading but eventually lets her foot, crossed over her leg, swing in his direction and touch his knee.
When the reading is over, he says, “Let’s take a walk.”
They begin walking, away from the crowds.
“I wanted to tell you this last night—”
He stops, sighs. On the narrow paved paths of the campus, the voices behind them grow distant.
“What is it?” she asks.
“Last night was amazing,” he says, “but—I’m married.” A pause, as if waiting for her reaction. “I’m sorry.”
She feels her heart kick the inside of her rib cage, a sharp swift jolt as if to tell her she should have known. “Why don’t you wear a ring?” she finally asks.
He looks down at his hand. “I lost it in the ocean a couple weeks ago. Down in San Diego.”
A cloak of disappointment envelops her body from the outside in, as if she’s the one underwater. Then she shrugs, a gesture that begins as an act but feels real by the time she speaks. She remembers a term Joel’s doctors had used after his surgery—positive margins—meaning the areas where some of the cancer might be left behind, any cells they couldn’t find and remove, and she thinks of how little can be known until it’s too late to do anything about it.
“It’s fine,” Rachel says. Then, recklessly, she adds, “I’d have done it anyway. It was worth it.”
In a move so swift she doesn’t have time to react, he moves close and kisses her, a feverish kiss she recognizes, as if he’s reached the same place of carelessness she has. Hidden by thick summer foliage, they sink down into the dirt under one of the large firs, her hands unbuckling his belt, his reaching under her sundress.
Afterward, as they lie looking up at the night sky through the needles of the tree, she says, “Why are you still married?”
“It’s not what you think. I love my wife.”
She lets out a short laugh. “That wouldn’t even hold up in a workshop,” she says. “Too clichéd. Come on, tell me.”
After a long pause, he says, quietly, “Sometimes the clichés are true, you know. You get busy with careers. With raising your daughter. And then the kid leaves and there’s nothing between you anymore.”
She turns onto her side, propping her head up, and looks at him. “Well,” she says, “now you’ve created quite a little plot twist for yourself.”
He sits up, brushing the dirt and pine needles off his back. He stands but doesn’t offer his hand, and she doesn’t move to join him. She remains sitting under the tree as she watches him walk away.
*
She goes to the morning workshop only so Todd won’t think she’s avoiding him. Again, he barely looks at her. She skips the afternoon sessions to write, determined not only to finish her assignment but to make it into exactly what she wants. She writes all day, and by evening, her back is tired and aching.
She skips the readings and spends the rest of the night in meditation, or what she’s come to think of as meditation—that suspension of time in which she lets the stories come to her, in which she reworks them in her head until everything is as she wishes it could be, or could have been. Editing out her mistakes, her broken family, her incipient relationships. Backspacing over everything so she can outline a new life for herself, something that might lead her, finally, to the sort of ending she’s always wanted.
*
On the last day, they critique two pieces before getting to hers. She feels oddly calm.
“Rachel’s story, ‘Meditation for Writers,’ draws some interesting parallels between meditation and writing,” Julia begins, “and, of course, it has a strong sense of the physical. So what do you think the author is really trying to do here?”
“Whatever it is, I feel like she’s trying too hard,” someone says.
“Yeah, the part where the guy tells her he’s married is a total cliché,” adds another. “And claiming he lost his wedding ring in the Pacific? I feel like the main character is too cunning to let him get away with that.”
“No, she’s gullible,” Christina says. “I think that’s the point—that she bought into it, and the guy felt guilty. That’s why he couldn’t perform that second time, under the trees. Because his lie was nagging at him.”
Rachel pretends to take notes in her journal, lifting her eyes to steal a glance at Todd as the others continue talking about the story. He’s staring down at her pages, his face utterly still but otherwise revealing nothing. And in that moment she regrets what she’s done—or at least, the way in which she’s done it. You’re the only one who can control your own narrative, her therapist says—yet for Rachel, this only feels true on the page.
“Ultimately,” Julia says, as she begins to wrap up the critique, “even though this story feels inauthentic at times, the writer clearly has a passion for the subject of sex and relationships, and this can be channeled into more successful pieces.”
“It’s really well written,” one writer says, “but I don’t know what she’s trying to say.”Julia agrees. “I think the best thing the author can do,” she says, “is to accept where the story wants to go.”
*
Rachel heads downstairs for the farewell reception, pausing on the floor below when she glimpses Todd crossing the hall. He’s in jogging clothes, toiletry kit in hand, and he shuts his door and heads toward the bathroom down the hall. He doesn’t see her.
She tiptoes down the hall, and, when she hears the shower running, she tries his door. It’s unlocked. She steps inside and closes the door behind her. The room looks the same as it did the night she was here; nothing has changed.
She opens the drawer of the desk and lets her hand pass over his car keys, spare change, receipts. He hasn’t unpacked anything. She doesn’t know it at first, but as she rifles through his open duffel, she realizes she’s looking for his wedding ring. Finally, at the bottom of one of the inner pockets, she finds it.
She holds it up—a thick, plain gold band—and, after studying it for a moment, she returns it to its hiding place. She turns to leave, then pauses by the desk. She picks up his pen, the Montblanc, and looks at his name, etched in the reflective black resin.
She opens the door. Down the hall, the shower has gone silent. She pockets the pen, then closes the door behind her, as if she’d never been there at all.
###
This story originally appeared in Stonecoast Review Issue 17.
Photo by Siora Photography.
And, naturally, this piece from Midge Raymond is exquisite.